Contents
- Choose the evidence before choosing the format
- Separate assessment formality from assessment purpose
- A decision guide for choosing an approach
- Prepare one shape set for both approaches
- Informal assessment: observe, question and record
- Formal assessment: a planned individual check
- Matching answer and interpretation guide
- Worked records: what the evidence does and does not show
- Interpret independence, prompts and materials separately
- Plan the evidence and the next teaching decision
Choose the evidence before choosing the format
Start with the question you need assessment to answer: can this pupil describe a shape's properties, sort by a stated rule, or explain why a shape belongs? Then choose how to collect the evidence and how you will use it. Do not let the label “informal” or “formal” make those decisions for you.
Formality and purpose are separate choices. AITSL's classroom illustration explicitly includes both informal and formal practices within formative assessment: teachers use evidence to adjust teaching and respond to pupils' understanding. AITSL: Formative assessment in the classroom
Use the paired tasks below for one goal: describe and sort two-dimensional shapes by stated properties, using the number of straight sides and vertices to explain a placement.
This goal draws on England's mathematics programme of study, which includes identifying and describing properties of two-dimensional shapes and comparing and sorting shapes by their properties. Its guidance also calls for precise mathematical vocabulary. Department for Education: National curriculum in England — mathematics programmes of study
Separate assessment formality from assessment purpose
For planning, use “informal assessment” for evidence gathered through the flow of classroom activity, such as listening to an explanation or watching a pupil sort. Use “formal assessment” for a deliberately organised check with specified tasks, conditions and a record reviewed against the goal. Treat these as working distinctions, not a rule that informal means oral and formal means written.
ASCD describes formal assessments as generally providing evidence from all pupils on particular learning targets for systematic review. Its examples include exit cards and purposeful note-taking, not just tests. It describes informal assessment as useful for understanding pupils in context, but less useful for establishing every pupil's position against a particular target. ASCD: The Why, What, and When of Assessment
Informal approach: allow the conversation to follow the pupil's choices; note the task, exact response and any help; use what you notice to select a follow-up question or teaching move.
Formal approach: specify the task and available resources beforehand; obtain an individual response from each pupil; keep a consistent record so you can review evidence against the same goal.
Keep purpose on a separate line in your plan. Write “formative” when you will use the evidence to decide what to teach next. Write “summative” when you will use it to summarise what the pupil has demonstrated at a chosen point. If you intend both uses, identify each separately.
The classroom examples and pupil responses below are hypothetical. Informal, formative use: during sorting, a pupil groups by colour rather than the stated side-count rule. You clarify the rule and plan another property-sorting activity.
Formal, formative use: every pupil completes the same individual shape check; you use the responses to choose the next lesson's examples.
Informal contribution to a summative judgement: you review dated observations of individual explanations when writing a summary of demonstrated learning, alongside other evidence.
Formal, summative use: you use a planned individual check to record what each pupil demonstrated at the end of the sequence.
For a parallel planning example using equal groups rather than shapes, use Formative and summative assessment: plan both for one maths goal. It shows how to preserve a pupil's first response, record hints and link the evidence to a teaching decision.
A decision guide for choosing an approach
If your question is “What property is this pupil attending to?”, begin with informal observation and an open question. Record the pupil's choice and explanation before offering a different rule.
If your question is “Who can sort by this stated property?”, use a planned individual check. Give each pupil the same shape set and sorting rule, and record each response rather than relying on the class discussion.
If your question is “What help makes the task accessible?”, collect a first response, then introduce one change at a time: repeat the instruction, invite the pupil to point, or offer a mathematical hint. Keep the responses before and after that change separate.
If your question is “Does the recorded sort match the pupil's reasoning?”, combine a photograph or saved arrangement with a short individual explanation. NSW Department of Education recommends bringing together conversations, observations and products when gathering assessment information. NSW Department of Education: Actions to take
Do not substitute a chorus answer for an individual record. In the lessons examined in Going beyond structured observations, researchers found that chorus responses appeared to inform the teacher about the class collectively, but not individual learning; group work and teacher-supplied phrasing also limited evidence of individual understanding. Going beyond structured observations: looking at classroom practice through a mixed method lens
Prepare one shape set for both approaches
Prepare six plain shape cards. Put the identifying letter on the reverse so it does not become a sorting cue. Draw clear, closed outlines with straight sides and no decorative details.
A: an equilateral triangle.
B: a scalene triangle, turned so no side is horizontal.
C: a square.
D: a non-square rectangle.
E: a convex irregular quadrilateral with no equal sides.
F: a regular pentagon.
Keep colour and card size consistent.
Prepare these three shape-description cards for pupils to read or hear:
Group 1: Shapes with 3 straight sides and 3 vertices.
Group 2: Shapes with 4 straight sides and 4 vertices.
Group 3: Shapes with 5 straight sides and 5 vertices.
For this task, explain vertices as the corners of these shapes. Read the cards aloud if needed, without identifying which shapes match.
Keep the goal narrow: describing properties and sorting by the stated rule. Do not require correct shape names or polished written sentences as additional success conditions. Invite speaking, pointing or tracing where those response modes fit your assessment question, and record the mode used.
These classroom materials are not a standardised assessment. Use the response guide to describe evidence and choose teaching, not to assign a validated score, grade equivalence or pass threshold.
Informal assessment: observe, question and record
Place the shapes in a normal sorting activity. Select a small group of focus pupils in advance, but listen to one pupil at a time. Begin with “Put together shapes that you think belong together. Tell me your rule.” Record the pupil's own rule without treating it as an answer to a rule you have not yet stated.
Next introduce the shared goal: “Now sort them using these description cards.” Watch the pupil's first placements before intervening. Record which shapes were placed, moved or left out, and what the pupil said while deciding.
Use open prompts first:
“Tell me about this shape.”
“What rule are you using?”
“Why does this one belong here?”
“How did you decide about this turned shape?”
“Can you show me what you mean?”
Pause for the pupil's explanation rather than completing it.
If you decide to teach during the interaction, mark the point where teaching begins. For example, “Touch each side once as you count” directs the pupil towards a method. Keep the response after that prompt, but do not replace the first-response record with the improved answer.
INFORMAL OBSERVATION RECORD
Pupil: __________ Date: __________
Question I am investigating: __________
Shapes available: __________
Rule: pupil-chosen / teacher-stated: __________
First action or placement: __________
Exact words, gesture or tracing: __________
Resources used: __________
Other pupil involvement: __________
Teacher's exact prompt, if any: __________
Response after prompt: __________
Evidence suggests: __________
Still uncertain: __________
Next teaching action or check: __________
Formal assessment: a planned individual check
Use the same six shapes and three description cards for each pupil. Ask pupils to work individually. Allow them to move, turn, touch and trace the cards. Decide beforehand whether you will read instructions aloud and how pupils may explain. Record those conditions; the shape cards are task resources, not automatically evidence of teacher assistance.
PUPIL INSTRUCTIONS
Use the shape cards to answer these questions. You may move and turn them. You can explain by speaking and pointing, or by writing.
1. Sort every shape under a description card.
2. Choose one shape from each group. Describe its straight sides and vertices.
3. Look at the two triangles. Explain why they belong in the same group even though they look different.
4. Choose a shape with four sides. Turn it, then explain whether it still belongs in the same group.
Collect a first response to all four questions before adding mathematical hints. If a pupil needs help to continue, record the unfinished or uncertain first response, give the help, and capture the later response separately. Save the final arrangement through a photograph or a written list of card letters in each group.
INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT RECORD
Pupil: __________ Date: __________
Instructions read aloud: yes / no
Response mode and resources: __________
Q1: Group 1 cards: ____ Group 2 cards: ____ Group 3 cards: ____
Q2: Exact descriptions or demonstrated counts: __________
Q3: Explanation about the triangles: __________
Q4: Explanation after turning: __________
Teacher prompts, written verbatim and linked to question: __________
Changes after prompts: __________
Next teaching decision: __________
Matching answer and interpretation guide
Question 1: A and B belong in Group 1; C, D and E in Group 2; F in Group 3. The stated rule concerns sides and vertices, so differences in side length or orientation do not create extra groups.
Question 2: Accept descriptions matching the chosen card, such as “This has four straight sides and four corners.” Record whether the pupil uses “vertices”, another understandable term, or pointing and counting. A correct count obtained by touching each side is a valid strategy, not a misconception.
Question 3: A sufficient explanation is “They both have three straight sides and three vertices.” “They are both triangles” gives a name but does not yet explain the requested property. Follow up on the properties after recording that first response.
Question 4: A sufficient explanation is “It still has four sides and four vertices when I turn it.” An unchanged placement with no explanation records a sorting choice, but leaves the reason for that choice unresolved.
Review sorting, description and explanation separately. If sorting matches the rule but explanations are unclear, plan a short conversation rather than assuming either secure reasoning or lack of understanding. If the pupil counts accurately but sorts inconsistently, revisit how the stated property determines group membership.
Worked records: what the evidence does and does not show
Informal observation: Maya first puts the square on its own and says, “This one looks like a diamond.” After the teacher states the four-side rule, Maya traces its sides and places it with the rectangle.
Record: initial appearance-based grouping; then correct placement under the stated rule, using self-initiated tracing and no mathematical hint.
Interpretation: the first grouping was not a failure to follow an unstated rule. Next, ask Maya to explain the placement of the irregular quadrilateral; the square response alone does not establish how she will handle it.
Planned individual assessment: Ravi sorts every card correctly. For the turned triangle he says, “Three sides,” while touching each side. After turning the square, he says, “Still four.”
Record: correct sort and side-count explanations without teacher hints, using the available cards; no vertex description or count recorded.
Interpretation: Ravi has demonstrated correct sorting on this set and explained the side counts of the turned triangle and square. Check his description or count of vertices before judging the full target demonstrated. Do not rewrite the record as “without materials”; no such task was given.
Prompted response: Ellis places the pentagon in the four-side group and says, “Four.” The teacher says, “Touch each side once as you count.” Ellis counts five and moves it.
Record: first placement and count; the exact method prompt; corrected count and placement after the prompt.
Interpretation: Ellis used the prompted counting method successfully. Next, offer a fresh shape without that hint to investigate whether Ellis selects the method independently.
Language and explanation: Noor sorts correctly, points to the corners and says, “Four pointy bits.”
Record: correct placement and an indicated count of four vertices; the formal word “vertices” was not used.
Teaching decision: connect Noor's gesture and phrase to “vertices”. If precise vocabulary is also a target, record it separately rather than discarding the evidence about properties.
Interpret independence, prompts and materials separately
Write conditions as a description, not a single success code:
“Without teacher hints, using movable shape cards.”
“After the instruction was reread verbatim.”
“After the teacher directed the pupil to count sides.”
“After a peer identified the group.”
Keep these records distinct when deciding what the pupil has demonstrated.
Separate access to the task from help with the mathematics. Record reading a description card aloud differently from saying “This shape has four sides.” Record a pupil choosing to trace the sides differently from a teacher directing that strategy. Preserve the actual words whenever the distinction affects your next decision.
Compare like conditions where possible. If two records differ because one includes a mathematical hint, use that difference to plan a follow-up rather than treating the responses as equivalent. Choose the next check to resolve one uncertainty: following the rule, counting sides, explaining a placement or using vocabulary.
Plan the evidence and the next teaching decision
ASSESSMENT PLANNING TEMPLATE
Mathematics goal: __________
Question I need evidence to answer: __________
Purpose: formative / summative / both, with uses specified: __________
Approach: informal observation / planned individual check / combination: __________
Task and stated rule: __________
Pupils whose individual evidence I will collect: __________
Resources and response modes available: __________
Instructions I will give: __________
What I will capture before prompting: __________
How I will record prompts and later responses: __________
Evidence I will retain: conversation / observation / product: __________
If I see __________, I will teach or check __________.
If I see __________, I will teach or check __________.
Uncertainty needing another opportunity: __________
Complete the “If I see…” lines before teaching. For more help turning a response into a next step, Formative Assessment Strategies for the Classroom provides a decision-first routine, response-format choices and a short planning template.
Finish with a usable decision, not just a label. “Needs more assessment” is too broad. “Check whether the pupil can apply a four-side rule to a new irregular shape without a counting hint” identifies the evidence you still need.